The Hidden Costs of Not Having Workers’ Compensation Insurance in South Carolina

As a South Carolina business owner, you’re focused on growth, profit margins, and keeping your customers happy. But there’s one area where cutting corners could cost you everything: workers’ compensation insurance.

While South Carolina law requires most businesses with four or more employees to carry workers’ comp coverage, many small business owners either don’t know this requirement exists or think they can get away without it. The reality? The hidden costs of going without workers’ compensation insurance far exceed the premium you’d pay for proper coverage.

What South Carolina Law Actually Requires

Under South Carolina Code Section 42-1-170, any business with four or more employees—whether full-time, part-time, or seasonal—must carry workers’ compensation insurance. This includes:

• Retail stores and restaurants
• Construction companies and contractors
• Manufacturing facilities
• Professional services firms
• Agricultural operations with four or more employees

The only exceptions are businesses with fewer than four employees, sole proprietorships with no employees, and specific exempt classifications like real estate agents and some agricultural workers.

The Real Cost of Non-Compliance

1. Devastating Legal Penalties

Getting caught without workers’ comp in South Carolina isn’t just a slap on the wrist. The South Carolina Workers’ Compensation Commission can impose fines of up to $100 per day for each day you operate without coverage. For a business with 10 employees, that’s $1,000 daily—adding up to $365,000 per year in fines alone.

2. Personal Liability Exposure

Without workers’ comp, you lose the legal protections it provides. If an employee gets injured on the job, they can sue you personally for:

• Medical expenses (which can easily reach six figures for serious injuries)
• Lost wages
• Pain and suffering
• Permanent disability compensation

A single workplace injury lawsuit could bankrupt your business and put your personal assets at risk.

3. Stop-Work Orders That Kill Cash Flow

The South Carolina Workers’ Compensation Commission has the authority to shut down your business immediately if you’re operating without required coverage. Every day your doors are closed means:

• Zero revenue while fixed costs continue
• Lost customers who go to competitors
• Potential permanent damage to your reputation
• Stress on your remaining employees who may start looking for other jobs

4. The Compounding Effect

Here’s what many business owners don’t realize: the longer you operate without coverage, the more expensive it becomes to get compliant. Insurance companies view businesses with lapses in coverage as high-risk, often resulting in:

• Higher premiums when you finally purchase coverage
• Larger required deposits
• More restrictive policy terms
• Difficulty finding insurers willing to write your coverage

Real-World Example: The $300,000 Mistake

Consider “Mike’s Construction” (name changed for privacy), a small contractor in Charleston with six employees. Mike thought he was saving money by skipping workers’ comp coverage—until one of his roofers fell and broke his back.

Without workers’ comp protection:

• The injured worker sued for $250,000 in medical bills and lost wages
• Mike paid $50,000 in legal fees
• The business was hit with $15,000 in state fines
• Mike had to sell his personal home to cover the costs

Total cost: Over $300,000

The annual workers’ comp premium Mike was avoiding? Less than $8,000.

Beyond the Legal Requirements: The Business Case

Even if you could somehow avoid the legal penalties, operating without workers’ comp hurts your business in other ways:

You Can’t Bid on Many Jobs: Most general contractors, government entities, and large commercial clients require proof of workers’ comp coverage before they’ll even consider your bid.

Your Employees Know: Word travels fast in small business communities. When employees realize you’re not carrying required coverage, it sends a message that you cut corners on their safety and security.

You’re Always One Accident Away from Disaster: Even the safest workplaces can have accidents. Without coverage, you’re essentially gambling your entire business on nothing bad happening.

What Proper Coverage Actually Costs

The truth is, workers’ compensation insurance is often more affordable than business owners think. In South Carolina, premiums are typically calculated as a percentage of your payroll, varying by industry:

• Office workers: Often less than $0.50 per $100 of payroll
• Retail employees: Usually $1-3 per $100 of payroll
• Construction workers: $5-15 per $100 of payroll (depending on the specific trade)

For a small business with $200,000 in annual payroll and moderate risk, you might pay $2,000-4,000 per year for full coverage. That’s less than most businesses spend on their monthly rent.

Getting Compliant: Your Next Steps

If you’re currently operating without workers’ comp coverage, here’s what you need to do:

1. Don’t wait: Every day you delay increases your exposure to fines and liability
2. Get accurate payroll records: Insurers need precise payroll information to quote coverage
3. Understand your classification codes: Different types of work have different risk levels and rates
4. Shop around: Rates can vary significantly between insurance companies
5. Consider payment plans: Most insurers offer monthly payment options to spread the cost

The Bottom Line

The question isn’t whether you can afford workers’ compensation insurance—it’s whether you can afford to operate without it. The hidden costs of non-compliance far exceed the premium you’d pay for proper coverage.

As a South Carolina business owner, you work hard to build something valuable. Don’t let a preventable mistake destroy what you’ve created. The peace of mind that comes with proper workers’ comp coverage is worth far more than the premium you’ll pay.

---

Need help getting workers’ compensation coverage for your South Carolina business? Our experienced team understands the local requirements and can help you find affordable coverage that protects your business and employees. Contact us today for a free quote and compliance review.